Answer to James in Presidential El 2020 topic 1 by michaelb1 Hi, So as not to upset James or clutter the presidential topic I write a quick reply here. To the list owners take this down any time you want. This is only my reply to James. I have nothing else to say. If what I wrote in presidential topic that seemed to upset James so much and then list manager also, then do delete what I wrote in the presidential topic leading to this reply. James, Mark mentioned how we cannot apply natal rules to a mundane chart. That is what I addressed. I then gave examples how to work it. Or could you read my mind to know what I eventually wrote about natal and mundane. Is that something you have ever even thought about? I was not trying to get into anything. I was just making clear how we may go about using natal with a mundane chart and reference to Ptolemy. We knew about his thoughts on nativities and foundation charts in previous century and began looking into it back then. So then I am to remain silent because every one can read my mind? Also, that is pretty bold statement Mark made. Mark has every right to such a belief. I am or was not saying he didn't have such a right. A statement like that is begging for a debate, eventually getting off topic. Then, Why didn't you remind him what you told me. If this is only about the presidency why make such a statement like he did. If you, James or the list managers don't like what I wrote then Delete it, right now. But let me also remind you I wrote about Trump chart and the 'fenced in' area in Libra where the main ruler of time in his chart is. I think that is on page 9. You wanted presidential astro I gave it to you. It was probably something you have never considered. I had more to give but what's the point. No more. Then good day. As always, here is hoping You and Yours are as bug n virus free as can be. Michaelb Quote Sat Oct 24, 2020 8:31 am
2 by Mark Hello michaelb1, I am glad to see you back on the forum! I have responded to you in the thread. I very much look forward to exploring this topic with you further once the US election is over and the dust settles. However, I think to do such a topic justice it requires a new thread clearly devoted to the issue. I plan to organise that soon. You are mistaken though if you assume this issue is new to me or that I have not considered this issue in considerable depth. I had a massive debate with the Greek astrologer Thomas Gaziz on just this issue over a decade ago here on Skyscript. regards, Mark As thou conversest with the heavens, so instruct and inform thy minde according to the image of Divinity William Lilly Quote Sat Oct 24, 2020 12:17 pm